Current location - Health Preservation Learning Network - Health preserving class - If the northern expedition of Shu Han was not Zhuge Liang, but Han Xin, would it be successful?
If the northern expedition of Shu Han was not Zhuge Liang, but Han Xin, would it be successful?
The fall of Jingzhou and Nanjun was the beginning of Shu's prosperity and decline. Jingzhou's strategic position is very important. It can send troops to Wu Dong or capture Cao Cao from the north. Unlike Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition, Jingzhou can go by sea, which greatly reduces the difficulty of marching. The loss of Nanjun in Jingzhou has always affected the demise of Shu Han. During Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition, every time he used troops to deal with Cao Wei, he had to take Qishan Road and set the target in Longxi area. Zhuge Liang never set the goal of the Northern Expedition in Chang 'an or Tongguan, because Zhuge Liang, who has always been cautious, would not risk attacking Chang 'an alone. Once defeated, he is in danger of being wiped out.

It can only be said that Zhuge Liang lost some creativity in the battle. He belongs to the kind of gradual and steady nibbling, and after laying down, he still has to think about how to digest the land and people in this area. The difference in national strength between Shu and Wei made him seldom have the opportunity to send troops, and it was not easy for him to be deadlocked because of one wrong step. Han Xin wouldn't have to worry about that. He is in charge of the game. He has all kinds of creative ways of playing, but it is undeniable that his ways of playing are sometimes dangerous. Of course, there must be a gap between the two, but the gap is not that big. Han Xin's single change to Zhuge Liang is definitely not unified. Only when Han Xin joined Shu Han and was reused by Zhuge Liang can he make a comeback.

Judging from the record, Han Xin is indeed stronger than Zhuge Liang militarily, but his personal ability is difficult to change the world trend. In contrast, Xiang Yu, the overlord of Chu at that time, made many strategic mistakes, such as implementing the system of enfeoffment, such as moving the capital to Pengcheng and so on. Xiang Yu is nominally the master of the world, but the separatist forces are still very strong, which gives Han Xin the opportunity to divide and rule. On the other hand, Cao Wei pacified the north, occupied the core area of China, ruled well, and had abundant talents and strong strength. Even if Shu Han has Han Xin, I'm afraid it's hard to unify the whole country.

The success of Han Xin's Northern Expedition was largely due to Xiang Yu's division of the territory of the State of Qin into three Qin Dynasties, and all three kings were accomplices in surrendering to Xiang Yu, which led to the adultery of 20W foot soldiers. Old Qin people hated them, and both Sima Xin and Dong Kun were have it both ways, so Han Xin surrendered directly. Zhuge Liang: At that time, three generations of Cao family basically stabilized the situation in the north, and the people also supported it when they were resting. They have long forgotten what a great man is, and Cao Zhen's ability, status and power are far greater than Zhang Han's.

Zhuge Liang's ability is certainly there, but his mentality is wrong. In the early days, when Liu Bei had little power, he could grasp anything with one hand. When his power became more and more powerful, he had to authorize it. No matter how good it is for a person to set up a small business, it is impossible for a person to manage a large enterprise, and his energy and ability are not enough. Everyone's responsibilities are clearly defined in three outstanding heroes of early han dynasty. Han Xin is in charge of military affairs, Xiao He is in charge of logistics, Sean gives advice, and there are many people behind him. It is strange that Zhuge Liang can successfully do the work of three outstanding talents and be exhausted in the end. If it is Han Xin's Northern Expedition and Zhuge Liang himself is in the rear, the effect will certainly be much better.

The establishment of Korea is the credit of a group of people, not Han Xin alone. No matter how powerful people are, they can't beat five. There are objective reasons why Han Xin can be so fierce. The first is Xiao He and. Another one is Liu Bang. If Liu Bei hadn't died and Jingzhou hadn't been lost, Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition would have been much easier and had a great chance of success. But if he met Liu Chan, who wouldn't have a headache? For Han Xin, not only will the Northern Expedition not succeed, but it will probably be cheated by a traitor like Huang Hao. Han Xin is suitable for going it alone, but not for others. This kind of person with poor political quality and emotional intelligence can easily disappear into the complicated political situation in the late Shu and Han dynasties.

Zhuge Liang's game is already quite difficult to operate. After Liu Bei's army attacked Wu and was burned to the ground, Shu declined, and both the treasury and the army faced a shortage. Then pacify Naman and go to the Northern Expedition immediately. Every northern expedition is actually hollowing out the national strength of Shu Han. As a result of the Northern Expedition, many unexpected things happened. Ma Su lost the street pavilion, Li Yan sent a fake letter, Sun Quan sent his head to Hefei, and so on. There is no doubt that Han Xin has strong fighting capacity, but he is a general and only considers World War I.. Zhuge Liang is the prime minister, and there are too many things to consider. From a long-term strategic perspective, consider the overall situation. If you make a mistake, you must re-plan the overall situation.