This article does not express any opinions on this incident and related medical problems. I believe that the court and the authoritative department will make a fair judgment and appraisal, but only raise some questions about the media reports:

As a media organization, it has the right and obligation to report and expose social events, but the premise must be rigorous, objective and fair. However, in the recent two consecutive follow-up reports, as a news media, without any court judgment and authoritative confirmation from the Provincial Food and Drug Administration, let's not say for the time being whether the Xichang incident is only a case among millions of children. The 30-minute column of The Truth has a strong subjective judgment and biased tone. The background music, video atmosphere and shooting techniques created are not like reporting a phenomenon, but exposing an industry shady that seems to have been confirmed. The traditional medicinal bath passed down by Tian Ai JIU Tang and the whole Chinese nation has had an irreversible negative impact on consumers' thoughts. Many statements in the report are untrue or contrary to common sense, and the health club will explain them. We also hope that the media will respect facts and fairness when pursuing eyeballs and ratings.

The simple background of Tian: `

History: More than 400 franchisees in more than 70 years. Achievements: Solved troubles for thousands of children and mothers, and brought health. There are millions of people washing moxibustion. Before the judgment of the court in this case, the National 3 15 Consumers Association did not find any complaints about Mrs. Tian's adverse reactions after moxibustion. )

Question 1: Mrs. Tian's formula is a national patent product, which is used by hundreds of franchise stores all over the country. In fact, it is just a small bag with one child, instead of washing four or more children in a small bag as reported. The cost of raw materials is also between 12- 15 yuan, excluding fixed costs such as labor, taxes, and facade. As for the explanation of the unannounced visit to the clerk, let's not say whether the clerk knows the cost composition.

Question 2: Another mother said exactly the same phenomenon, but it was only a telephone interview and was corrected immediately. Needless to say, it seems that she heard on the radio that an aunt took some medicine and was cured after several years of illness. This strongly discredited report makes people feel that the media is really powerful.

Question 3: The bath water seems to be used. It can be said that no one uses bath water repeatedly. I don't know where this report or recording came from. Most of them are dumped on the spot or discharged directly from the bottom of the barrel after washing.

Question 4: Screenshots of recorded chats belong to the judicial category, which is another topic. After the court's decision, whoever commits perjury will be responsible. Recording and chatting screenshots are not directly related to the cause of Xichang children, but the media play is undoubtedly easy for consumers to make subjective judgments. Perjury is true, and the screenshot is true. Then the child's illness is also caused by moxibustion, which is also an inertial thinking. The responsibility of the media is to report and court. Even if the court finds it true, the author thinks it is irrelevant to this case. Belongs to another proposition. Nor can it be used as direct evidence of the cause of the child. At present, the chat record is only the reference of the public security organs, and it is the help of the detection direction. It cannot be used as direct evidence, not to mention that the chat record is a discussion rather than an execution. Chat screenshots themselves can also be PS.

Question 5: Physician qualification, a new term that really appeared in 30 minutes recently, is a medical bathing and health care institution. Like many Chinese medicine foot massage, it is a health care and fitness project institution, not a medical institution. As long as employees meet the relevant national health conditions and undergo professional training for a certain period of time, they can all take up their posts, but the information conveyed to consumers by media reports is undoubtedly the illegal operation of practicing medicine without a license;

Question 6:3 15, the process of wrapping eggs and medicine at night in the picture is almost fabricated. Tian's moxibustion hall never uses egg yolk to wrap medicine, and then wraps bigger pieces of medicine, while Tian uses fine medicine noodles.

Question 7: The relationship between Liu Jianqiong and Wang has been published online. We don't care about this. They are also colleagues and don't care about this. As far as the etiology is concerned, psoriasis is relatively easy to appear in rural areas, and it can be cured by drugs such as bezoar and wine, but it takes a long time; Why can't Liu Jianqiong's children walk at the age of four? Because her children have been suffering from this disease for a long time. She was given drugs that are easy to soften her body for a long time, and then tried it in Tian's moxibustion hall to see if it works, but since then, Hotan has forged such a deep hatred.