Current location - Health Preservation Learning Network - Health preserving recipes - Hua tuo was already dead when Guan Yu scraped the bone and treated the poison. Then who is treating Guan Yu?
Hua tuo was already dead when Guan Yu scraped the bone and treated the poison. Then who is treating Guan Yu?
Everyone should be familiar with the plot of Hua Tuo treating Guan Yu with curettage in Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Through this story, Guan Yu's bravery and fearlessness were highlighted, and Guan Yu became a god figure in the eyes of future generations. But in the real history, if Guan Yu really used bone scraping to treat poison, it must not be Hua Tuo, because Hua Tuo was already killed by Cao Cao. Then, if it was not Hua Tuo, who scraped Guan Yu's palace?

1. The so-called scraping is to scrape off the poison infiltrated into the bone with a knife, so as to achieve the purpose of detoxification.

Speaking of "scraping bones to cure poison", people usually think of Guan Yu and Hua Tuo. According to some records, the thing is this: once, Guan Yu was shot through his left arm by a flying arrow. Later, although the wound was closed after treatment, it still left sequelae. Every rainy day, the bone in his left arm will ache sharply. So Guan Yu's aides recruited doctors who could cure him.

A few days later, a man in plain clothes came to Guan Yu's camp.

The man said his name was Hua tuo. He heard that Guan Yunchang is a hero in the hearts of people all over the world. He came to treat Guan Yunchang because he was injured by an arrow in an accident. As we all know, Hua Tuo is one of the few outstanding surgeons in the medical history of China. Good at using anesthesia, acupuncture, moxibustion and other methods, good at thoracotomy. The method of operation is not the mainstream treatment method of traditional Chinese medicine based on the culture of respecting Confucianism. Under the proposition of Confucianism that "the strength of the body is what parents receive", surgery has not developed on a large scale in Chinese medicine.

2. How did Hua Tuo treat Guan Yu? After the examination, Hua Tuo said: "The arrow is poisonous, and now the poison has penetrated into the body with the blood and into the bones. If you want to completely solve the pain, you must cut off your arm and scrape off the bones contaminated by poison. "

Guan Yu thought for a moment, then stretched out his arm and asked Hua Tuo to treat himself.

At that time, Guan Yu just invited some generals to drink and eat together, and Hua Tuo was treating him. There is blood on his arm, but Guan Yu is still laughing.

However, according to another document, The History of the Three Kingdoms, although it did happen, it did not point out that Hua Tuo was treating Guan Yu. Seeing this, you may have a question, what is this? Was it really Hua tuo who treated Guan Yu at that time In other words, it was not Hua Tuo who treated Guan Yu, but someone else?

Don't worry, listen to me slowly.

According to the Records of the Three Kingdoms, Cao Cao once had a headache, and every time he got sick, he was upset and dizzy. Cao Cao invited many so-called famous doctors to treat himself, but nothing worked. By chance, Cao Cao heard from people around him that Hua Tuo's medical skills were excellent and he was the best among doctors. So Cao Cao sent someone to invite Hua tuo to treat him.

After Hua Tuo's treatment, Cao Cao's condition has obviously improved greatly. But Hua Tuo told him that this is an old illness, and it has been ill for too long, and it has been impossible to fundamentally eradicate it for him.

Seeing that Hua Tuo could really cure himself, Cao Cao wanted to keep him around, so he offered to be his own doctor and give him endless wealth.

The conditions proposed by Cao Cao are very attractive, but Hua Tuo doesn't care about wealth and fame. He just wants to go home and study prescriptions to help the world. Therefore, Hua Tuo asked Cao Cao for leave to go back to his hometown on the grounds of "seeking to return the party". During this period, Cao Cao repeatedly urged Hua Tuo to return to his side for treatment alone, but Hua Tuo just didn't want to go back and refused Cao Cao's request on the grounds that his wife was ill.

Hua tuo's action made Cao Cao feel very angry, and someone dared to disobey his orders so blatantly. So, in 208 AD, Cao Cao sent people to Hua Tuo's hometown to investigate. It's a good thing we didn't investigate After investigation, we found that Hua Tuo's wife was completely healthy and there was nothing wrong with her. In a rage, Cao Cao arrested Hua Tuo and then ordered Hua Tuo to die.

Probably because of the causal cycle, not long after Hua Tuo's death, Cao Cao's favorite son became seriously ill. But because I couldn't find a doctor as skilled as Hua Tuo, I missed the opportunity of treatment and died. Later, Cao Cao recalled this incident and sighed, saying that he regretted killing Hua Tuo, which led to the death of his son.

It can be seen from here that Hua Tuo died in 208 AD. It was mentioned earlier that Guan Yu curetted bones to treat poison, but it happened in AD 2 19. At that time, Hua Tuo had died for eleven years. How could he cure Guan Yu by scraping bones and healing wounds?

3. Who was the person who treated Guan Yu's poison? It turned out that in order to pass on his medical skills and benefit future generations, Hua Tuo taught all his medical skills and prescriptions to his disciples. Among them, Upp and Fan A are outstanding representatives among many disciples of Hua Tuo. Upp mainly studies the art of helping people keep healthy, while Fan A studies Huatuo's acupuncture and surgery. These two people have their own strengths and achievements in their respective fields.

Based on the story of the Three Kingdoms and the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, we mentioned that "Hua Tuo" was Guan Yu's treatment method of scraping bone and curing poison, and suggested that Ma Feisan should be used before moving the knife. The person who calls himself Hua Tuo should be Fan A. Because Hua Tuo has made great achievements in surgery, he often treats patients with unexpected and bold methods, so he is called "the imperial doctor" by the world.

Hua Tuo's deeds of helping patients to operate and traveling all over Shan Ye to find prescriptions are widely circulated among the people, and are well known, and people admire him very much. There are also rumors that Fan A's medical skill even exceeds that of Hua Tuo, so it is not surprising that people mistake the deeds of Hua Tuo's disciples for those of Hua Tuo.

Hua tuo was already dead when Guan Yu was scraping the bone to cure poison, so who was treating Guan Yu?

It is said that Fan A took medicine with the pharmaceutical technology of "lacquer leaf sticking powder" taught by Hua Tuo, and lived to 100 years old.