After listening, it can't be said that it is unexpected, but it is probably reasonable, because knowing the direction of her lecture at the beginning can predict the way and basic content of the lecture later.
? I don't like to judge others, but if I have to define her, I think she is a magic stick in the coat of traditional Chinese medicine.
? She is a person who doesn't understand Chinese medicine. She has no clinical experience and can't save people. She just uses a set of Chinese medicine theories and her own opinions to fool ordinary people, that is to say, she has no medical skills and skills. From your last conversation, I learned that she said that she disdained to talk about superficial things like "skills" and had risen to the realm of medical care and life. I don't think she has reached this level. She just doesn't know or speak medical skills, but she loves to talk. After being questioned about some medical skills, she defended herself to the public with a set of self-deception statements. This is not an honest scholar.
? Of course, I admit that she has also played a positive role in the development, dissemination and promotion of Chinese medicine. Many women and children in junior high schools can get to know Chinese medicine or enjoy Chinese medicine health care, which has caused a wave of health care upsurge among the people and even made many students fall in love with Chinese medicine and go to a professional college of Chinese medicine. These are all positive aspects, which are undeniable. But there is no need to put her on the altar, she doesn't have that height.
? She is a person who caters to the public psychology with a little professional knowledge, talks about some sensational views to attract people's attention, and writes books to make money, not a doctor. Of course, she is not a doctor, but when ordinary people see her in Kan Kan and talk about Chinese medicine, they take it for granted that she is a happy doctor.
? She is a professor at Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, but she doesn't teach medicine. Specifically, she is an associate professor in the Department of Medical Humanities, School of Basic Medicine, Beijing University of Chinese Medicine. In fact, she teaches literature. Teaching ancient literature in ancient medical classics belongs to language and literature. Therefore, in her speech, she always likes to explain Chinese medicine from the text, decipher the text, trace the source and make various conjectures. Of course, there are also correct ones, but there are too many incorrect interpretations of the text, or they are far-fetched and self-righteous. Few ordinary people will make an in-depth study of Chinese characters, let alone ancient Chinese characters. Of course, whatever she says is what she says. There is no scholar who is rigorous about academics at all. However, if she admits that she writes books, there is nothing wrong with studying from the perspective of a writer. Writers can make things up, they don't need authenticity, and they don't need to be responsible to the public. However, I heard that she was really going to write a novel, and she even boasted that I wrote the hottest novel.
? People who haven't really studied medicine are easily fooled by her theory, and think that what she said about Chinese medicine is mysterious, interesting, powerful or easy to understand, which makes sense. She is used to using metaphors, all kinds of popular analogies and all kinds of associations related to people's lives. This may be the reason why ordinary people are willing to accept it. It's easy to understand. However, in professional medical colleges, some students bluntly said that "there will be some' fans' among the freshmen, but the higher the grade, the fewer people believe in her." Some students even said, "She is just an ancient Chinese teacher, teaching medicine unprofessionally and rubbish.". I believe this is the real feeling of the students, because I can't listen to her class for a few minutes from an amateur angle, and there are many mistakes.
? She also has many alarmist views, such as "lung cancer patients = perfectionists", "men have stomach problems, and they are either angry with their bosses or their wives", "middle-aged lustful" and so on. And even the title is grandstanding "Let health be completely clear". God dare not use this word easily. The human body is so complicated that it changes all the time. Physicians of all ages failed to fully explain human health and diseases throughout their lives, and she did not have the ability. Why did you choose such a title? Without it, it's just a commercial purpose. Without such an eye-catching name, how can we attract the attention of the general public and be willing to pay for it? Most people in China don't want to think independently, but like to trust authority and other people's conclusions. They can get the opinions set by others without thinking, think they have the truth with a few unverified opinions, show off their strength everywhere and learn everywhere. Lazy, love to take shortcuts, want to gain knowledge or health through a book. Isn't that the title they have in mind?
? Since I have heard a class and felt a lot, I will pick out some of her fallacies as an unprofessional person to discuss.
She said: "The Emperor's Internal Classic is the only book named after the holy king, which means that in ancient culture, studying life is regarded as the emperor's business, which is a great merit and great compassion."
? The study of life is a matter for human beings, not for emperors. Only the emperor has the right to pursue health. The study of life is the same concern of human beings, who have been concerned about birth, aging, illness and death since the beginning of human beings. To say that the occupation of the God King is nothing more than pulling an authority to improve credibility. By the way, it virtually aroused people's desire for success. Only by listening to her words and practicing in her way can we have a healthy body, make great achievements and pay homage to others.
? Traditional Chinese medicine is the experience of China's ancestors in fighting diseases for thousands of years, which is summarized bit by bit. At first, we explored practical treatment methods without theoretical support. Like many animals, they also have some basic treatments, and even some clever animals chew up some herbs to apply wounds. They don't know why, and there is no theoretical support. They are just exploring the instinct of survival. Those who were successfully rescued were written into genes from generation to generation and became instinct. Humans, on the other hand, have higher wisdom, summed up enough experience, and then found appropriate ideas such as the art of war of Yin and Yang and the theory of five elements as the theoretical basis of traditional Chinese medicine in an era when a hundred schools of thought contend, thus guiding the medicine of later generations. This theory is the emperor's internal classic.
? According to textual research, Huangdi Neijing was written after Historical Records of the Western Han Dynasty. This wonderful book was written by doctors of past dynasties and named Huangdi Neijing. China people always have the habit of naming names. Many great poets and writers, such as Li Bai and Su Shi, are all works named by later generations. If you don't have the authoritative name of the Yellow Emperor, and your name hasn't been handed down, who will believe it and how can it be passed down from generation to generation? This is a fact that all doctors know and admit, but Qu Limin actually said it was a conversation between the Yellow Emperor and his teacher, and told me what the Yellow Emperor was like. Just like she was there.
Only when the Buddhist scriptures are predestined can we hear the dharma, and only when everyone is predestined can we hear her dharma. You can't just listen to her talk about Huangdi Neijing. It's really good to flatter yourself with Buddhist words.
? Later, I will talk about Buddhism and say that the human body has been cultivated for thousands of years.
? Later, he said, "China is hard to live: as a China native, you should be grateful and proud. Only China has so many classics. " .
You've been rambling and talking nonsense. As a scholar of traditional Chinese medicine, it is difficult for you to talk about medicine. You are always talking about something, Buddhism, nationality, and playing emotional cards. According to her, as outsiders, they don't know how to be grateful, and they all feel inferior and want to die.
What is her exotic culture, the classics of Greek Tessa, and the awakening of the Renaissance? Without foreign advanced ideas of democracy, freedom and fairness, she is still a handmaiden wrapped in little feet and carrying urine and water. When it's really fooling primary school students, such remarks dare to make a fool of themselves.
? "Why don't China people buy things from North and South?" She asked this question, but it is common sense for anyone who has studied history. The word "thing" originated from the eastern and western markets in the Tang Dynasty. At that time, Chang 'an's trade was prosperous, and the eastern market sold domestic goods, while the western market sold foreign goods, mostly from the western regions. People go to the east and west markets to buy goods, which has evolved into shopping.
? However, it is far-fetched for her to mechanically apply the five elements theory. It is said that the east belongs to wood, the west to gold, the south to fire and the north to water. Wood and gold are bearable things, that is, things with substance, while water and fire are unbearable things. Then he said: In the era of drawing water with bamboo baskets, Jin Mu can carry it, but fire and water can't. Focus on "the era of drawing water with bamboo baskets". Excuse me, which era in human history is drawing water with bamboo baskets? When did humans become so stupid? Human intelligence is inferior to that of animals. She can make a fuss about such proverbs as historical evidence. Really unable to spit.
? It is also said that China people call names and talk about culture: "You are not something" is not something but the north and south, and the north and south belong to fire and water, and fire and water are ruthless. This is a fabrication of random association. If we really want to say this, then according to the east, south, west and north of China, it belongs to benevolence, righteousness, courtesy, wisdom and faith, and the south just belongs to righteousness. How can she justify herself? Alas! It seems that she is really nothing.
? "buying and selling things, not buying east or buying west. The operator gives birth and wants to buy a sunrise enterprise; The West is converging and there are profitable companies. "
? Then when it comes to the north and south, I dare not compare with the growth of the south and the collection of the north. The topic suddenly turned to the contrast between the five elements of fire and water in the north and south, which means that fire and water are oil and ammunition. It is said that fire and water will do harm to human beings if they enter the human trading society. At present, all social unrest is related to oil and arms.
? Take the hot words such as sunrise enterprises and money-making enterprises in today's commercial stock market and people's desire for money to confuse the audience and make random analogies. Water and fire have existed in the market for thousands of years. Don't you think she doesn't need fire and water in her life? She is just a primitive man who eats and drinks blood.
? Who can say that no country can live without arms? In modern life, no one can live without oil. The development of all science and technology has both advantages and disadvantages for society. We can't enjoy the convenience of science and technology, and at the same time be a godmother who insults science and technology. Unless she can stay away from everything, be independent and attack at will.
? What does social unrest have to do with oil and arms? Without oil and arms, there would be no turmoil and war in the world? It's like a person who drinks wine and does what he can, but blames alcohol. Wine is innocent, but sin lies in people's hearts. Money is not guilty, and sin is also in people's hearts. Everything is innocent, and the crime lies in people's hearts. Why blame arms and oil?
? In fact, these nonsense can be used to explain Chinese medicine by involving the fire and water in the north and south, saying that "the Yellow Emperor's Canon is the loneliest, and the sages have been lonely since ancient times." The goal pursued by western society is to know oneself. "A patchwork of words, patchwork, meaningless. If you don't know what to say, it's meaningless. He is good at stealing concepts, confusing people, making random analogies, and quickly fading out and changing the content of the conversation when he can't justify himself. There are too many fallacies to elaborate.
? Anyway, he is not a rigorous scholar or a medical person. But it is true that she is not a medical student. She only works in literature, telling stories may be ok, or teaching the relationship between Chinese medicine and traditional culture. This kind does not belong to medicine, but belongs to Chinese medicine culture, which is more casual and can have many stories to enhance people's interest in Chinese medicine. Some predecessors have also made up stories and will imagine and guess. Besides, I also learned some professional theories, made my own subjective assumptions, wrote down all kinds of shocking conclusions, and even misinterpreted the original medical theories.
? People who are new to medicine and don't know much about medicine are easily attracted by her amazing theories of bestsellers. If ordinary people just want to know a little about Chinese medicine, keeping in good health by themselves or talking about it after dinner, it doesn't matter, it doesn't hurt, and reading books doesn't hurt, it's just a personal problem. However, if you are really interested in learning real medicine, trust her and learn from her, it will be extremely misleading and will harm others and yourself.
? If you really want to learn Chinese medicine, then I suggest not reading her books. Learn honestly from the basic theory of TCM, TCM diagnostics, recipe, TCM, TCM internal medicine, TCM surgery, TCM gynecology, TCM pediatrics and so on. Then read China ancient medical classics such as Huangdi Neijing and Treatise on Febrile Diseases.
? I am too weak to be a good teacher. I just recommend it according to the procedure. As for Qu's books or remarks, I am firmly opposed to them. With my shallow knowledge, I can pick out her numerous fallacies, not to mention being a professional medical worker. In others' eyes, she may just be a buffoon.
? Alas! Say too much, stop here, don't say much.