Associated with the above problems, it seems a mystery what is the relationship between Jia Baoyu and Qin Keqing. The fifth time, Jia Baoyu went to the Qin room for a nap and wrote: "Just arrived at the door, a thin fragrance came to the nose. Baoyu thought his eyes were soft and even said, "It smells good! When I entered the room and looked at the wall, there was a picture of Haitang sleeping in spring painted by Tang Bohu. On each side there is a couplet written by Qin Taixu, a scholar in the Song Dynasty. The couplet says: "tender and cold locks dreams because of warm spring, and fragrance is wine." "There was a precious mirror in the case, which was set in the mirror room of Wu Zetian that day. There was a gold plate with a swallow standing and dancing on it. An Lushan threw a papaya in it, which hurt too much milk. Princess Shou Chang and His Royal Highness Zhang Han share a couch and have couplets written by Princess Tongchang. Baoyu said with a smile, "It's so nice here!" Qin smiled and said, "I can live in this house, and maybe there is a fairy who can live in it." "In this way, I personally unfolded the gauze worn by Huan and moved the pillow held by the matchmaker ..." Many researchers think this description is a metaphor for Qin Keqing's chaotic life. From this, I think Qin Keqing contacted Baoyu and the fairy Ke Qing in his dream and seduced Jia Baoyu in the bedroom. In addition, the thirteenth time, Baoyu heard the news of Qin Keqing's death from his sleep. "It was like being stabbed in the heart, and wow, his mouth was full of blood." In response to these two sentences, Jia Xu was originally critical: "Baoyu has long been determined to continue housework, but I'm sorry. Now that he is dead, he is very disappointed. " Urgent fire strikes the heart, how can you not have this blood? Sigh for jade. I'm afraid this sentence is not the author's intention. Imagine that Jia Baoyu, who is "down and out, stupid and afraid of reading articles", should care about Jia's family affairs. Isn't this a strange conversation? Wang Xilian, the owner of flower protection in the Qing Dynasty, commented: "Baoyu was heartbroken and vomited blood after hearing Qin's vicious letter. The sex in my dream is so charming. Sure, why not? " Obviously, Ke Qing and Qin Keqing, fairies of Ningguo Mansion, are considered to be the same person.

In this case, we might as well make such an extension: Jia Baoyu's life tragedy is, first, the tragedy of being a man, because he has repeatedly said that he will turn to ashes after his death and will no longer be a man; The second is the tragedy of being born not as a daughter, but as an ugly person; Thirdly, since Qin Keqing, he has experienced the love between men and women again, which shows that he has bid farewell to his wonderful childhood and entered an irritating adolescence, and experienced the tragedy of human death for the first time through the death of Qin Keqing.